Who Pays the Broker Fee Now
The Fairness in Apartment Rental Expenses (FARE) Act is Local Law 119 of 2024. It took effect June 11, 2025. The Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP), which enforces it, sums it up this way:
“This law prohibits brokers who represent landlords from charging broker fees to tenants. This includes brokers who publish listings with the landlord’s permission.”
In practice, DCWP’s FAQ sets out three rules.
- A landlord’s agent can’t charge you. The law prohibits a landlord’s agent from charging fees to prospective tenants, and that includes listing agents. In the FAQ’s terms, a landlord’s agent “represents the landlord in the rental of an apartment” and a listing agent “publishes apartment listings with the landlord’s permission.” There is a “rebuttable presumption” that an agent who publishes a listing does so with the landlord’s permission or authorization.
- The landlord is liable as well. A landlord is liable if the landlord’s agent charges a fee to a tenant to rent an apartment, or if the listing agent does.
- No one can make you hire a broker. Landlords or their agents can’t condition the rental of an apartment on tenants retaining a particular agent, and no one can condition it on tenants hiring a broker, including a dual agent. A dual agent acts as both the tenant’s agent and the landlord’s agent.
The exception: a broker you hire yourself
The law does not prohibit tenants from choosing to hire their own broker and pay broker fees. Tenant brokers can also advertise their services, in DCWP’s words, “so long as the broker does not condition the availability of specific units or identifiable inventory on the broker being hired by a tenant.”
What the law leaves alone
The FAQ notes that the law does not prohibit landlords from charging prospective tenants for background checks and credit checks; it points to subdivision 1 of section 238-a of the state Real Property Law for those. On fees agreed before the law took effect, DCWP says the prohibition “may not apply to a contractual obligation for a tenant to pay a fee for a broker’s services that arose before June 11, 2025, depending on the particular circumstances under which the obligation arose.”
What a Listing and the Landlord Must Disclose
The law also covers how fees are shown to you. According to DCWP’s FAQ:
- In a listing or advertisement, no one can include an unlawful broker fee, and all fees that prospective tenants must pay to rent the apartment must be disclosed in a clear and conspicuous manner.
- Before the lease, landlords or their agents must give you an itemized written disclosure of all fees you must pay the landlord, or anyone at the landlord’s direction, to rent the apartment. Each fee must have a written description, and you must sign the disclosure before you sign the lease.
- Afterwards, the landlord or agent must keep the signed disclosure for three years and give you a copy.
Other fee rules, including the one for background and credit checks, are in the NYC rental facts reference.
Advertisements
Penalties for Charging a Prohibited Fee
DCWP’s FAQ describes the process: if DCWP determines that a person violated the law, it issues a summons, and the respondent can appear before the NYC Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH) to respond. Then:
“If the charges are sustained, the violator will be issued a civil penalty and may be required to pay restitution for any illegal fees charged to tenants.”
The caps in the law
- Charging a prohibited fee, requiring a broker, or posting an unlawful fee (§ 20-699.21): “not more than $1,000 for the first violation and not more than $2,000 for each subsequent violation occurring within a two-year period.”
- Failing to disclose fees (§ 20-699.22): “not more than $500 for the first violation and not more than $1,000 for each subsequent violation occurring within a two-year period.”
Quoted from Admin. Code § 20-699.23(a) and (b): Local Law 119 of 2024, NYC Council file Int 0360-2024.
DCWP’s penalty schedule
Within those caps, DCWP adopted a penalty schedule, 6 RCNY § 6-89, effective July 10, 2025. Each amount has a second figure in a column the rule heads “Default”.
| Rule column | Fee violations, § 20-699.21 (a), (b), (c), (d) | Disclosure violations, § 20-699.22 (a), (b) |
|---|---|---|
| First violation | $750 | $375 |
| First default | $1,000 | $500 |
| Second violation | $1,800 | $900 |
| Second default | $2,000 | $1,000 |
| Third violation | $2,000 | $1,000 |
| Third default | $2,000 | $1,000 |
| Fourth and subsequent violation | $2,000 | $1,000 |
| Fourth and subsequent default | $2,000 | $1,000 |
Source: DCWP, Notice of Adoption, 6 RCNY § 6-89. The rule lists each provision on its own line with these amounts: § 20-699.21(a), “Agent liability for unlawful imposition or collection of fee for residential rental”; § 20-699.21(b), “Landlord liability for unlawful imposition or collection of fee by agent”; § 20-699.21(c), “Unlawful conditioning of residential rental on engagement of an agent”; § 20-699.21(d), “Unlawful fees posted in listing”; § 20-699.22(a), “Failure to disclose in residential rental listing all fees to be paid by tenant in a clear and conspicuous manner”; § 20-699.22(b), “Failure to provide tenant with itemized fee disclosure for residential rental”. These are the amounts the rule sets, not amounts collected.
Two lines in the rule affect how the amounts add up. “Each subdivision, paragraph, subparagraph, clause, item, or other provision charged in the Notice of Violation shall constitute a separate violation of the law or rule.” And a second or later violation means one by the same respondent, for the same provision, “within two years of the prior violation(s).”
You can also sue
“The Law creates a private cause of action, which allows individuals to sue in civil court.”
The law’s text adds that the court “may order compensatory, injunctive and declaratory relief” (Admin. Code § 20-699.24). Whether a lawsuit makes sense for you is a question for a lawyer or a tenant legal-services group, not this page.
How to File a Complaint With DCWP
DCWP’s File a Consumer Complaint page names “forced broker fees” among the things to complain about, and lists three ways to file:
- Online: a866-dcwpbp.nyc.gov/consumer-complaint/file-complaint. The page says you do not need to create an account to file.
- By mail: download and complete the complaint form from that page and send a copy, with copies of related documents (not originals), to NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, Consumer Services Division, 42 Broadway, New York, NY 10004.
- By fax: the same form, to (212) 487-4482.
What to include. DCWP’s FARE Act page asks you to “provide as much evidence as possible (e.g., text messages, screenshots, receipts, contact information) and include the name and contact information of the broker if available.”
What happens next. For consumer complaints in general, DCWP says it “uses mediation to resolve complaints.” Its overview of the process says that during mediation DCWP sends a copy of your complaint to the business for a written response, and that copies of all your correspondence are forwarded to the business.
How complaints have actually arrived. Of the 1,503 broker-fee complaints in the data, 798 are marked as received online, 639 through 311 and 66 by email or fax. The 311 figure is an observation from the dataset; DCWP’s filing page itself lists the three routes above.
The Data: Complaints and Charges So Far
The city’s public complaint data holds 1,503 complaints with a broker-fee code, logged by the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) from May 14, 2025 to September 23, 2026. DCWP’s charges data shows 150 counts under the FARE Act sections in 97 cases against 82 businesses or individuals, dated July 11, 2025 to July 14, 2026.
Read these as activity, not as verdicts. A complaint is an allegation, not a finding that the law was broken. The numbers also stop where the city’s published data stops: the complaints dataset was last updated November 2, 2026 and its newest complaint of any kind is dated September 25, 2026. No business or person is named on this page.
Complaints by month
Broker-fee complaints peaked at 321 in June 2025, the month the law took effect; from September 2025 to August 2026 each month had 53 to 79
DCWP consumer complaints with a broker-fee code, by the month DCWP logged them, May 2025 to September 2026
September 2026 is partial and drawn lighter: the newest complaint of any kind in the dataset is dated September 25, 2026, and it holds 27 broker-fee complaints for that month so far. 29 complaints were logged before the law took effect on June 11, 2025. Every complaint in the dataset has a result recorded, so complaints DCWP has not finished with may not be published yet, and recent months could still rise.
Show the numbers
| Month | Complaints |
|---|---|
| May 2025 | 3 |
| June 2025 | 321 |
| July 2025 | 190 |
| August 2025 | 150 |
| September 2025 | 79 |
| October 2025 | 67 |
| November 2025 | 68 |
| December 2025 | 53 |
| January 2026 | 60 |
| February 2026 | 73 |
| March 2026 | 77 |
| April 2026 | 66 |
| May 2026 | 62 |
| June 2026 | 75 |
| July 2026 | 61 |
| August 2026 | 71 |
| September 2026 (partial) | 27 |
Source: NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, DCWP Consumer Complaints (nre2-6m2s) via NYC Open Data; complaints with a broker-fee code; dataset last updated November 2, 2026, pulled November 20, 2026.
What the complaints were about
DCWP tags each complaint with one or more codes. “Broker Fee Listed” is the most common, on 890 of the 1,503 complaints (59%). The codes say what the person complained about; they do not say what DCWP concluded.
59% of broker-fee complaints say a broker fee appeared in a listing
Share of the 1,503 complaints carrying each DCWP complaint code, May 14, 2025 to September 23, 2026
- Broker Fee Listed890 complaints59%
- Broker Fee Charged487 complaints32%
- Required to Use Agent226 complaints15%
A complaint can carry more than one code (181 do), so the shares add up to more than 100%. 60 of these complaints also carry the code "Fees or Surcharges Not Disclosed".
Show the numbers
| DCWP code string, as published | Complaints |
|---|---|
| Broker Fee Listed | 758 |
| Broker Fee Charged | 417 |
| Required to Use Agent | 147 |
| Required to Use Agent; Broker Fee Listed | 59 |
| Fees or Surcharges Not Disclosed; Broker Fee Listed | 29 |
| Broker Fee Charged; Broker Fee Listed | 25 |
| Fees or Surcharges Not Disclosed; Broker Fee Charged | 16 |
| Other - Z01; Broker Fee Listed | 9 |
| Fees or Surcharges Not Disclosed; Required to Use Agent | 8 |
| Broker Fee Charged; Required to Use Agent | 7 |
| Exchange/Refund/Return; Broker Fee Charged | 6 |
| Other - Z01; Broker Fee Charged; Broker Fee Listed | 3 |
| Advance Fee Charged; Broker Fee Charged | 2 |
| Unauthorized charges; Broker Fee Listed | 2 |
| Fees or Surcharges Not Disclosed; Broker Fee Charged; Broker Fee Listed | 2 |
| Fees or Surcharges Not Disclosed; Required to Use Agent; Broker Fee Listed | 2 |
| Other - Z01; Broker Fee Charged | 2 |
| Fees or Surcharges Not Disclosed; Broker Fee Charged; Required to Use Agent | 2 |
| Overcharge; Broker Fee Charged | 1 |
| Advertising/Non-Availability - A03; Broker Fee Charged | 1 |
| Advertising/Misleading - A02; Advance Fee Charged; Broker Fee Charged | 1 |
| Advertising/Misleading - A02; Broker Fee Listed | 1 |
| Other - Z01; Required to Use Agent | 1 |
| Non-Delivery of Goods - N01; Advance Fee Charged; Broker Fee Charged | 1 |
| Other - Z01; Fees or Surcharges Not Disclosed; Broker Fee Charged | 1 |
Source: NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, DCWP Consumer Complaints (nre2-6m2s) via NYC Open Data; complaints with a broker-fee code; dataset last updated November 2, 2026, pulled November 20, 2026.
Complaints by borough
Brooklyn business addresses account for 37% of the broker-fee complaints that list a borough
Complaints by the borough of the business complained about, May 14, 2025 to September 23, 2026; 1,289 of 1,503 complaints list one of the five boroughs
- Brooklyn474
- Manhattan376
- Queens325
- Bronx101
- Staten Island13
211 complaints have no borough and 3 are marked "Outside NYC"; they are not charted. The dataset defines the field as "The NYC Borough where the business is located", so it is the address of the landlord or agent, which may not be where the apartment is. These are counts, not rates: boroughs differ in how many rentals they have.
Show the numbers
| Borough of the business | Complaints | Share of those with a borough |
|---|---|---|
| Brooklyn | 474 | 37% |
| Manhattan | 376 | 29% |
| Queens | 325 | 25% |
| Bronx | 101 | 8% |
| Staten Island | 13 | 1% |
| No borough recorded | 211 | |
| Outside NYC | 3 |
Source: NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, DCWP Consumer Complaints (nre2-6m2s) via NYC Open Data; complaints with a broker-fee code; dataset last updated November 2, 2026, pulled November 20, 2026.
How the complaints reached DCWP, and how they ended
53% of broker-fee complaints came in online
The 1,503 complaints by the intake channel DCWP recorded, May 14, 2025 to September 23, 2026
Show the numbers
| Intake channel | Complaints | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Online | 798 | 53% |
| 311 | 639 | 43% |
| Email/Fax | 66 | 4% |
Source: NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, DCWP Consumer Complaints (nre2-6m2s) via NYC Open Data; complaints with a broker-fee code; dataset last updated November 2, 2026, pulled November 20, 2026.
The dataset gives each complaint a result. The labels are DCWP’s, and the most common, “Complaint Review Complete”, says only that the review is complete. It does not say the complaint was upheld or rejected, and this page does not read it either way.
| Result, as DCWP labels it | Complaints | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Complaint Review Complete | 1,304 | 87% |
| Requested Information Not Provided | 176 | 12% |
| Insufficient Info Received | 11 | <1% |
| Referred | 7 | <1% |
| Duplicate Complaint - DUP | 5 | <1% |
Source: NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, DCWP Consumer Complaints (nre2-6m2s) via NYC Open Data; complaints with a broker-fee code; dataset last updated November 2, 2026, pulled November 20, 2026.
Advertisements
Charges DCWP has brought
Separately from complaints, DCWP publishes the charges it files; the dataset describes them as charges issued “during the course of an inspection” or filed “stemming from an investigation”. DCWP’s charges data shows 150 counts under the FARE Act sections in 97 cases against 82 businesses or individuals, dated July 11, 2025 to July 14, 2026. One case can include several counts and more than one section. “Unlawful conditioning of residential rental on engagement with an agent” (§ 20-699.21(c)) is the most charged, with 72 of the 150 counts.
| Section and what it covers | Counts | Cases |
|---|---|---|
| § 20-699.21(c)Renting the apartment was made conditional on the tenant hiring an agent.Law: “No person shall condition the rental of residential real property on a tenant engaging any agent, including but not limited to a dual agent.” | 72 | 53 |
| § 20-699.21(d)A listing said fees must be paid in a way the law forbids.Law: “No person shall post a listing for the rental of residential real property that represents that fees must be paid in a manner that would violate this section.” | 49 | 41 |
| § 20-699.22(a)A listing did not clearly disclose a fee the tenant would have to pay.Law: “Every listing related to the rental of residential real property shall disclose in such listing in a clear and conspicuous manner any fee to be paid by the prospective tenant for the rental of such property.” | 12 | 12 |
| § 20-699.21(a)(1)A landlord’s agent charged a tenant a fee.Law: “a landlord’s agent shall not impose any fee on, or collect any fee from, a tenant related to the rental of residential real property” | 7 | 7 |
| § 20-699.21(a)(2)An agent who published the listing with the landlord’s permission charged a tenant a fee.Law: “any agent who publishes a listing for a rental of residential real property with the permission or authorization of the landlord for such property shall not impose any fee on, or collect any fee from, a tenant related to the rental of such property” | 5 | 5 |
| § 20-699.21(b)(1)The landlord is in violation because its own agent charged a tenant a fee.Law: “A landlord is in violation of subdivision a of this section if: 1. a landlord’s agent of such landlord violates such subdivision” | 5 | 5 |
| All FARE Act sections | 150 | 97 |
Source: NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, DCWP Charges (5fn4-dr26) via NYC Open Data; charges citing Admin. Code § 20-699.21 or § 20-699.22; dataset last updated November 2, 2026, pulled November 20, 2026. Law text: Local Law 119 of 2024, NYC Council file Int 0360-2024. The cases column adds up to more than 97 because a case can cite several sections.
How the charges ended
Of the 150 counts, 104 have an outcome recorded: 83 are marked guilty, 3 not guilty and 7 dismissed, and 11 were withdrawn. The other 46 counts have no outcome in the data. That may mean they are still pending; the dataset does not say.
104 of 150 FARE Act counts have an outcome recorded; 46 do not
Counts charged under Admin. Code § 20-699.21 and § 20-699.22 by the outcome DCWP recorded, charges dated July 11, 2025 to July 14, 2026
- No outcome recorded23 cases46
- Default Decision28 cases42
- Hearing Decision23 cases29
- Settlement (Pre-Hearing)13 cases20
- Charges Withdrawn9 cases11
- Settlement (Post Hearing)1 case2
Outcome labels are DCWP's. "Marked guilty" is the dataset's guilty column, which it defines as the "Number of counts where the respondent was found guilty via decision"; in this data it is also filled on settlements and default decisions. The dataset has no penalty or restitution amounts.
Show the numbers
| Outcome, as DCWP labels it | Counts | Cases | Marked guilty | Not guilty | Dismissed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No outcome recorded | 46 | 23 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Default Decision | 42 | 28 | 42 | 0 | 0 |
| Hearing Decision | 29 | 23 | 19 | 3 | 7 |
| Settlement (Pre-Hearing) | 20 | 13 | 20 | 0 | 0 |
| Charges Withdrawn | 11 | 9 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Settlement (Post Hearing) | 2 | 1 | 2 | 0 | 0 |
Source: NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, DCWP Charges (5fn4-dr26) via NYC Open Data; charges citing Admin. Code § 20-699.21 or § 20-699.22; dataset last updated November 2, 2026, pulled November 20, 2026.
Method, Sources and Limits
How this page is made. The figures were generated by a script from NYC Open Data on November 20, 2026. The text was written with AI assistance and checked against the DCWP and City Council pages cited below on November 20, 2026. This is not legal advice.
Data
- Complaints. DCWP Consumer Complaints (nre2-6m2s), NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. Filter, exactly as run:
(complaint_code like '%Broker Fee%' OR complaint_code like '%Required to Use%'). That matches DCWP’s codes “Broker Fee Listed”, “Broker Fee Charged” and “Required to Use Agent”. Matching complaints were logged May 14, 2025 to September 23, 2026; the dataset was last updated November 2, 2026. - Charges. DCWP Charges (5fn4-dr26), same agency. Filter, exactly as run:
charge like '%20-699.2%', which matches Admin. Code § 20-699.21 and § 20-699.22 and nothing else (checked on each run). A count is one unit of the dataset’s charge count; a case is one record ID; a business is one DCWP business ID, which can be a company or an individual. Matching charges are dated July 11, 2025 to July 14, 2026; the newest charge of any kind is dated August 28, 2026, and the dataset was last updated November 2, 2026.
Limits
- Complaints are allegations. Nothing in the complaints data says whether a complaint was valid.
- Published data lags. All 81,625 complaints in the dataset, of every type, have a result, so open complaints may not be included yet. Blank charge outcomes may be pending cases.
- The filter can miss complaints. Since June 11, 2025, another 326 complaints against a “Landlord or Real Estate Agent” carry the code “Fees or Surcharges Not Disclosed” without a broker-fee code. Some may concern the FARE Act’s disclosure rules; the data does not say, so they are not counted.
- Borough is the business’s address. 211 complaints have no borough, and the counts are too small and too loosely located to map by neighborhood.
- No dollar figures. The charges data has no penalty amounts. No broker-fee complaint has an amount in the complaints data’s refund columns. This page gives no typical fee, because no official source for one was found.
Legal sources
- NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, “Fairness in Apartment Rental Expenses (FARE) Act” page and FAQ (page says “Last Updated 6/02/2026”)
- New York City Council, Int 0360-2024 (version A), enacted as Local Law 119 of 2024
- NYC Rules, penalty rule for Local Law 119 of 2024 (status: Adopted; effective July 10, 2025)
- DCWP Notice of Adoption, 6 RCNY § 6-89 “Fees for Rental of Residential Property Penalty Schedule”
- DCWP, “File a Consumer Complaint”
- DCWP, “What Happens to Your Complaint”
All six were read on November 20, 2026. Related reading on DwellCheck: how to find an apartment in NYC, moving to NYC and NYC renter rights.
Questions and Answers
1Who pays the broker fee in NYC now?
Since June 11, 2025, New York City’s FARE Act prohibits brokers who represent landlords from charging broker fees to tenants. That includes brokers who publish a listing with the landlord’s permission. The law does not stop you from choosing to hire your own broker and paying that broker’s fee. A landlord is also liable if its agent or the listing agent charges a tenant a fee to rent an apartment (NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, FARE Act FAQ, last updated June 2, 2026).
2Do I have to pay a broker fee to rent an apartment in NYC?
Not to the landlord’s broker or the agent who published the listing. DCWP’s FAQ says the law prohibits a landlord’s agent, including a listing agent, from charging fees to prospective tenants, and that no one can condition the rental of an apartment on tenants hiring a broker. If you choose to hire your own broker, the law does not prohibit that broker’s fee. The law also does not prohibit a landlord from charging for background and credit checks, which state law covers separately.
3When did the FARE Act take effect?
June 11, 2025. The City Council approved the bill, Int 0360-2024, on November 13, 2024; it was enacted on December 13, 2024 as Local Law 119 of 2024 and took effect 180 days after it became law (NYC Council legislation file; DCWP FARE Act FAQ).
4Can a landlord or agent require me to hire a broker?
No. DCWP’s FAQ says landlords or their agents can’t condition the rental of an apartment on tenants retaining a particular agent, and that no one can condition the rental of an apartment on tenants hiring a broker, including a dual agent (an agent acting for both the tenant and the landlord). In DCWP’s charges data, that provision (§ 20-699.21(c)) accounts for 72 of the 150 counts charged under the FARE Act, more than any other section.
5What is the penalty for charging an illegal broker fee in NYC?
Local Law 119 of 2024 caps the civil penalty for charging a prohibited fee at $1,000 for a first violation and $2,000 for each later violation within two years, and for a disclosure violation at $500 and $1,000. DCWP’s adopted penalty schedule (6 RCNY § 6-89) sets a first violation at $750 for a prohibited fee and $375 for a disclosure violation. DCWP’s FAQ says a violator may also be required to pay restitution for any illegal fees charged to tenants.
6How do I report a broker fee in NYC?
DCWP’s complaint page lists three ways: online at a866-dcwpbp.nyc.gov/consumer-complaint/file-complaint, by mail to NYC Department of Consumer and Worker Protection, Consumer Services Division, 42 Broadway, New York, NY 10004, or by fax to (212) 487-4482. DCWP asks for as much evidence as possible, such as text messages, screenshots, receipts and contact information, and the broker’s name and contact information if you have them. You do not need an account to file online.
7How many broker fee complaints has NYC received?
The city’s public complaint data holds 1,503 complaints with a broker-fee code, logged by the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection (DCWP) from May 14, 2025 to September 23, 2026. The most in one month was 321, in June 2025; from September 2025 to August 2026 each month had 53 to 79. A complaint is an allegation, not a finding that the law was broken. DCWP’s charges data shows 150 counts under the FARE Act sections in 97 cases against 82 businesses or individuals, dated July 11, 2025 to July 14, 2026. Figures are from NYC Open Data, pulled November 20, 2026.