Neighborhood Comparison

Astoria vs Long Island City: Which NYC Neighborhood Is Better in 2026?

Western Queens head-to-head: multi-ethnic Astoria with its legendary food scene and low-rise charm versus Long Island City's glass-tower skyline and 5-minute Manhattan commute.

Data from 2026-09-14·Both in Queens
an aerial view of a city with tall buildings
Photo by Zoshua Colah on Unsplash

Overall Livability Score

Astoria
6.2/10
#8 of 27 Queens neighborhoods scored from NYC Open Data
Long Island City
6.3/10
#7 of 27 Queens neighborhoods scored from NYC Open Data

Winner: Long Island City by 0.1 points

Dimension-by-Dimension Breakdown

Each dimension is scored 0-10. A dimension with no data behind it is shown as not measured and left out of the comparison.

Financial

No comparison: not measured
AstoriaNot measured
Long Island CityNot measured

Outdoor & Green

Winner: Astoria
Astoria6.2/10
Long Island City6/10

Commute

Winner: Long Island City
Astoria7/10
Long Island City9.5/10

Investment

No comparison: not measured
AstoriaNot measured
Long Island CityNot measured

Livability (ART)

Winner: Astoria
Astoria2.6/10
Long Island City2.2/10

Practical

Winner: Astoria
Astoria8/10
Long Island City7/10

Key Stats at a Glance

StatAstoriaLong Island City
Subway stations nearby46
Trees within 200m137120
Largest park in or nearRalph Demarco ParkMurray Playground
Avg days on market——
Borough rank (within scoring model)#8 / 27#7 / 27

The Verdict

Astoria

Astoria scores 6.2/10 composite—a neighborhood with strong transit and few housing violations, hampered by moderate noise.

Long Island City

Long Island City scores 6.3: exceptional for commuting, held back by noise and above-average crime.

Top Strengths

Astoria

  • +Few housing violations — Practical score of 8/10 (borough median 8.0) reflects a low rate of HPD housing violations per residential building
  • +Multiple parks within walking distance — The 3 nearest parks average 443m from the neighborhood's center; parks include Ralph Demarco Park and Whitey Ford Field
  • +Established dining and cultural scene — Greek cuisine heritage and documented diverse dining options create neighborhood identity and foot traffic

Long Island City

  • +Exceptional transit connectivity — Commute score of 9.5 (borough median: 3.5); eight subway lines serve six stations with minimal walking distance
  • +Park access — The 3 nearest parks average 263m from the neighborhood's center
  • +Cultural amenities and waterfront — MoMA PS1, waterfront parks, and Manhattan views differentiate the neighborhood from surrounding industrial Queens

Things to Consider

Astoria

  • −Moderate noise complaint volume — 9,217 noise complaints recorded (Moderate category), indicating ongoing street-level sound issues

Long Island City

  • −Moderate noise levels — 2,486 noise complaints in 12 months reflect active construction, traffic, and high population density
  • −Above-average crime — Crime held stable over 12 months (-1.6%); 2,452 total crimes give a lower crime rate per resident than 4% of Queens neighborhoods

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Astoria or Long Island City better for renters?

Based on current DwellCheck data, Astoria scores 6.2/10 overall (#8 of 27 Queens neighborhoods scored from NYC Open Data) and Long Island City scores 6.3/10 (#7 of 27 Queens neighborhoods scored from NYC Open Data). "Better" depends on what you weight — see the dimension-by-dimension breakdown below for a side-by-side.

Which neighborhood has better transit: Astoria or Long Island City?

Astoria has 4 subway stations in our data and scores 7/10 on commute. Long Island City has 6 stations and scores 9.5/10. The commute score counts the subway stations inside each neighborhood and the number of lines they serve.

Which is greener: Astoria or Long Island City?

Astoria: 137 trees expected in a 200m circle (NYC Parks tree inventory); 6.2/10 outdoor. Long Island City: 120 trees expected in a 200m circle (NYC Parks tree inventory); 6/10 outdoor. Parks listed: Ralph Demarco Park (Astoria) and Murray Playground (Long Island City).

Is Astoria or Long Island City safer?

Safety varies block-by-block within any NYC neighborhood. Check the specific address you're considering on DwellCheck for an NYPD crime count within 300m of the building. Neighborhood-level averages are useful starting points but can mask individual block differences of 5x or more.

Which is better for families: Astoria or Long Island City?

Family-friendliness depends on the outdoor, practical, and commute dimensions plus specific factors like school quality and playground density. In our data, Astoria scores 8/10 practical and 6.2/10 outdoor; Long Island City scores 7/10 practical and 6/10 outdoor. School quality data is not included in these scores — use nyc.gov/schools for that.

How recent is this comparison data?

Neighborhood guide data was last generated on 2026-09-14, and the neighborhood averages shown here come from that run. For block-level data, the DwellCheck address lookup queries NYC Open Data when a report is calculated and caches it for up to 14 days; NYPD publishes crime data quarterly, and 311 data updates daily.

Check a Specific Address

Neighborhood averages are a starting point. Block-level safety, crime, and building health vary widely within any NYC neighborhood. Check the exact address before you sign.